Is the Wait Over?
Mohsin is a member of The Motley Fool Blog Network -- entries represent the personal opinion of the blogger and are not formally edited.
The obesity industry is new on the stock block, but it has already become one of the most followed industries in our market. The two major competitors Vivus (NASDAQ: VVUS) and Arena (NASDAQ: ARNA) have both received FDA approval for their drugs. Orexiegen (NASDAQ: OREX) is still trying to get approval for its obesity treatment Contrave. Vivus has already launched its obesity pill Qsymia into the US market. The launch of Arena’s Belviq was initially delayed as the company had to wait for a DEA review of the abuse potential of Belviq. It has partnered with Eisai to launch the drug in America; while this reduces a lot of risk on the part of Arena, it reduces margins as well, as the company has to pay 33% from all wholesale collections to Eisai.
In my recent articles on the obesity sector I have discussed the market potential of both drugs and compared both products as well. In my most recent article on Arena, I discussed the market impatience with the launch of Belviq. The market was expecting Arena to give a clear schedule for Belviq launch during its recent conference call. The company failed to live up to the Street's expectations and did not give a clear guidance on Belviq launch. The stock slipped 6% on the news, but the company has already regained its pre-conference valuation.
Arena not only let investors down by not announcing concrete information on Belviq launch, but also missed the Street’s earnings expectations. The Street was expecting Arena to post quarterly EPS of $-0.03, but the company missed expectations and posted earnings of $-0.10. This was the third time in the last four quarters that Arena has failed to live up to expectations. However, at this stage the earnings for the company are irrelevant as the stock is moving on Belviq news. Although the stock has recovered, the company will have to provide solid information on the drug launch.
In more bad news for Arena investors, the market is becoming more pessimistic on European approval of its obesity treatment. According to a couple of research firms, the chances of Belviq approval in Europe are now pretty slim. Needham and Oppenheimer have both suggested to their investors that the tough regulatory environment in Europe will likely result in rejection for Belviq. The competing drug Qsymia has already failed to receive approval in Europe due to potential cardiovascular risks that the drug might pose.
Vivus has been asked by the European Medicines Agency's (EMA) Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) to perform an additional pre-approval cardiovascular outcomes trial for Qsvia (Qsymia). Although both drugs have a different mechanism and safety profile, with Qsymia more risky, the lack of approval does set a bad precedent for Belviq. The analysts have also said that even if Belviq is approved in Europe the reimbursement rates will be pretty low, which will impact the valuations of Arena.
The company has failed to meet Street’s earnings expectations or provide any solid information on the launch of Belviq. The real worry for investors should be the increasing pessimism of analysts on the approval of Belviq in Europe. The launch has been delayed but will happen sooner than later, and any news regarding this launch will push up the stock price of Arena. Despite this temporary bad news, I still believe Arena is a strong buy. In my opinion the obesity market is big enough for more than one player. Qsymia, Contrave and Belviq can all become blockbuster drugs and make a lot of money for the investors of their respective companies.
SmartEquity has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Is this post wrong? Click here. Think you can do better? Join us and write your own!