Keystone Could Set The Bar High
Reuben is a member of The Motley Fool Blog Network -- entries represent the personal opinion of the blogger and are not formally edited.
TransCanada's (NYSE: TRP) proposed Keystone pipeline has been mired in government red tape for years. With a massive body of information and increasingly stringent regulations floated as requirements for the project's approval, all pipeline companies may be impacted by the project, even if it gets turned down.
The Keystone pipeline is intended to bring oil from Canada's oil sands region down through the United States to the U.S. Gulf Coast. There it would be used as feedstock for refineries and reduce the country's dependance on Middle Eastern oil.
That sounds like a winning proposition, but there have been debates about everything from how many jobs it will create to how safe it is to let the pipeline cross over important watersheds. Environmental issues have been the biggest sticking point, with approval now bogged down in politics.
Safety is a clear concern, and it's an area on which Keystone could have a lasting impact for the entire pipeline industry. For example, Bloomberg reports that TransCanada is being asked to put in writing that it will pay for the damage from any oil spills.
If that's not enough to put a scare into a pipeline company, consider the fact that Joe Oliver, the Canadian minister of natural resources, told the Bloomberg New Energy Finance Summit that "the new pipe itself would have 57 more safety features than are found in the hundreds of thousands of miles of pipelines already crisscrossing the U.S."
Pipeline companies, then, could see increased safety regulations because of the contentious battle over Keystone. That risk will be there even if the pipeline never gets built.
How to Play
Investors who see and rightly fear the risk that Keystone will lead to increased industry regulation should probably stick to the companies most capable of affording such changes.
A Giant without a Partner
Enterprise Products Partners (NYSE: EPD) is one of the largest limited partnerships (LPs) in the pipeline space. Its operations span the country and just about every aspect of the midstream space. It has been a reliable dividend grower and its business has expanded rapidly.
Well financed, it could easily afford the impact of new regulation. Of course its size means that it would face massive changes, but those costs would likely be passed on to customers relatively quickly.
One nice feature about Enterprise is that it doesn't have a general partner (GP). Thus, the incentive distributions that other companies in the LP space pay to their GPs get put toward growth and/or unit holder distributions.
That said, this LP is an industry leader and is afforded a premium price. Conservative investors willing to trade yield for safety might find Enterprise of interest.
Complex Structure Discount
Kinder Morgan (NYSE: KMP) is every bit as impressive as Enterprise, but normally trades at a discount. That's because Kinder still has a GP. It also has a share class that pays stock dividends instead of cash dividends. Basically, the business structure is much more complex than that of Enterprise.
It is, however, large and well financed. So, if there are any negative industry implications from the Keystone project, Kinder in all of its forms will be able to handle the changes. The complexity, meanwhile, leaves investors with a chance to get a little more yield than they would with Enterprise.
For income investors, its worth the extra effort to get to know Kinder. For those who want exposure to an LP in an tax advantaged account, like an IRA, meanwhile, Kinder's stock dividend share class (KMR) is the ideal option. Cash distributions from LPs don't play well with tax sheltered accounts.
The Problem Child
TransCanada is actually a pretty solid option for investors despite the Keystone fiasco. It is a massive pipeline player in Canada and has been diversifying its business beyond its current reliance on natural gas pipelines. That's on top of an energy business that already provides a good amount of diversification and support for the company's modest dividend.
The Canadian pipeline company is not an LP, so its dividend yield is below that of Kinder or Enterprise. However, it is financially strong, and TransCanada has shown that it is capable of taking on big projects and long fights. So, if the rules change after Keystone gets approved or denied, TransCanada should be able to handle the impact and be well versed in the changes.
Investors, meanwhile, seem to like the company's prospects with or without Keystone, since the shares have been on a fairly steady climb over the past few years. That said, if Keystone isn't approved, the shares are likely to trade lower on the news. That could be a good buying opportunity.
Yield or Growth
Enbridge (NYSE: ENB), with a market cap of nearly $38 billion, is another industry giant. It has pipeline assets spanning both Canada and the United States. The Canadian company also owns a natural gas utility that serves Canada and some U.S. regions near the boarder.
The company makes more liberal use of debt than some of its industry peers, with debt accounting for around 70% of the capital structure. However, Enbridge is financially strong and would easily be able to make any improvements to its systems that new regulation might require. Like TransCanada, however, it is not an LP, so its dividend yield, at less than 3%, is low relative to the LPs with which it competes.
That said, the company is the general partner for Enbridge Energy Partners (NYSE: EEP). Although this LP's $9.5 billion market makes it fairly small relative to Enterprise ($55 billion) and Kinder ($33.5 billion), its parent company has the heft to keep Enbridge going through any difficult times. Its around 7% yield is notably higher than that offered by the two larger LPs, making Enbridge Energy Partners a good option for income investors.
Enbridge Energy Partners is also likely to benefit from drop down transactions from its general partner, which means there is also meaningful growth potential at the LP. General partners often sell legacy assets with stable, but slow growth, cash flows to their controlled limited partnerships to free up capital for growth. As a small LP, even tiny transactions could meaningfully increase Enbridge Energy Partners' growth.
Changes from Unexpected Places
Industry changes can come from all different places. Right now, the Keystone debate in the United States looks like a slow motion regulatory nightmare. Sticking to the big industry players, however, should provide ample protection from any rule changes that the Keystone debate might be telegraphing.
The growing production of natural gas from hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling is flooding the North American market and resulting in record-low prices for natural gas. Enterprise Products Partners, with its superior integrated asset base, can profit from the massive bottlenecks in takeaway capacity by taking on large-scale projects. To help investors decide whether Enterprise Products Partners is a buy or a sell today, click here now to check out The Motley Fool's brand new premium research report on the company.
Reuben Brewer has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Enterprise Products Partners L.P.. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Is this post wrong? Click here. Think you can do better? Join us and write your own!