If You’re Still Chasing This Stock, Do So at Your Own Risk
Neha is a member of The Motley Fool Blog Network -- entries represent the personal opinion of the blogger and are not formally edited.
This stock has been on a tear. After putting on a massive 61% last year, it still has the spring on its feet alive. Manitowoc (NYSE: MTW) has already gained 17% this year. The crane maker’s stock outperformed most peers in the past twelve months, including bellwether Caterpillar (NYSE: CAT) by a gaping margin.
I just have one question: Why is this stock rallying? Just why? A lot of things suggest Manitowoc is in bad shape; bad enough to encourage anyone to take some profits off the table. Fundamentals nor valuations excite me about this stock right now.
26*70 is a scary number
A company sells a small chunk of its business (one which not many knew even existed) and decides to use the proceeds to dump some of its debt. Sounds good, eh? Not when you know that the ’proceeds’ are as good as one hair on a full head. That’s the case with Manitowoc, which plans to put $26 million generated from the recent sale of its warewashing business to knock off a debt. Well, Manitowoc shoulders over $1.8 billion of debt.
Huge debt isn’t a new problem for Manitowoc. It existed ever since Manitowoc let out a victorious cry in 2008 when it edged out Illinois Tool Works (NYSE: ITW) to take over equipment-maker Enodis in a $2.7 billion deal. It was a risky bet for a business unrelated to Manitowoc’s core expertise, and it came at a heavy cost, the price of which the company is still paying. Manitowoc’s history is replete with instances of it selling off bits and pieces of its business only to generate some funds to pay down debt. The story remains, and Manitowoc has just left most wondering whether the hefty bet for Enodis was a wise one.
More than four years down the line, humongous debt continues to weigh it down, and the foodservice-equipment business has failed to show the growth desired. I dug deep into Manitowoc’s financials for the past few years, which threw up these woeful numbers.
|Food-service equipment business||2012||2011||2010||2009|
|Earnings from operations||241||216||203||167|
Figures in millions.
Since the Enodis acquisition, Manitowoc’s foodservice-equipment business is yet to register double-digit growth on top line. Last year was the best in terms of earnings growth, but it rode on declining sales, which means cost-cutting worked behind the scenes. So that can’t really be termed growth. 2013 won’t be exciting either with the company expecting ‘mid-single digit’ revenue growth for the business.
Manitowoc’s free cash flow is measly for its debt at around $44 million with net income just about double of that. Cash flows and profits have hardly grown over the past four years (as you can see in the graph above), making it tougher for the company to balance growth while strengthening its financials. Don’t expect a clean balance sheet so soon – Manitowoc aims to shave off just around $200 million of debt this year.
Doesn’t stack well
So while Manitowoc reels under pressure, Illinois Tool Works’ margins have edged up over the years. In fact, Terex (NYSE: TEX) is the only company Manitowoc manages to beat in its game. Others trump it easily, and there’s reason.
Illinois Tool Works competes with Manitowoc primarily in the food-service equipment space, but that’s just one part of its portfolio. While Manitowoc runs two businesses, Illinois Tools Works is a mega conglomerate that makes equipment catering largely to transportation and power industries. Packaging and chemicals are some other businesses it manages. So the diversity allows Illinois Tool Works to tackle business cycle swings well, and offset weakness in one business with strength in another.
Caterpillar is digging greater benefits out of its mining business than construction; and the former has actually emerged as its face-saver and profit machine in recent times. Deere (NYSE: DE) is known more for its tractors than excavators or loaders. Dominance in the resilient agriculture sector means Deere can maintain margins even when its other business, construction and forestry, faces headwinds. By now, you must have already guessed why Terex lags the group. With construction equipment as its main and sole business, Terex is the hardest hit by economic downturns.
Strangely, the two worst performers also command the highest valuations at today’s price. Markets probably see a lot of hidden potential, as evidenced by the sharp fall in their forward P/E.
|Company||Profit margin||Operating margin||Return On Equity||Trailing P/E||Forward P/E|
Source: Yahoo! Finance
But where will the growth come from for Manitowoc? On its construction side, Brazil is an opportunity as Manitowoc’s new factory rolls out rough-terrain cranes in time for World Cup 2014. The company is expanding in China as well, which is also Caterpillar’s favorite investment zone. Construction activity in the U.S. is also picking up, albeit slowly. Manitowoc’s crane orders slipped 19% in the last quarter, confirming the sluggishness. On the foodservice front, it all depends on Manitowoc’s customers. If they grow, so will Manitowoc. One of them, McDonald’s, plans to open 1,500 to 1,600 restaurants this year. It sounds good, but the restaurant industry has too many challenges to tackle to expect boisterous growth so soon.
The Foolish bottom line
In short, Manitowoc’s story doesn’t justify its premium valuation. Its current prices and recent run up suggests expectations might have already been factored in. Europe is another serious concern. Manitowoc is trying to cut down costs, but as long as revenue and cash flows do not grow, it will be a tough game.
I’d prefer paying attention to Manitowoc’s peers right now. What about you? Shoot off your views in the Comments section below.
Neha Chamaria has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Illinois Tool Works. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Is this post wrong? Click here. Think you can do better? Join us and write your own!