Are We Sure This Is Progress?

Chad is a member of The Motley Fool Blog Network -- entries represent the personal opinion of the blogger and are not formally edited.

When investors hear about a merger of two powerful companies, they usually expect that there will be some short term pain, but long-term gain. However, once in a while, a merger doesn’t go as expected and investors are left wondering what went wrong? Unfortunately, it seems this might be happening with Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK). Duke merged with Progress Energy to create an energy powerhouse. However, the cost wasn’t cheap, as Duke had to issue millions of new shares and take on debt to make this happen. Since these two companies have become one, there are several troublesome numbers that suggest the combined entity’s growth may not progress the way investors expect.

Mergers are exciting, but growth is what matters
Pretty much no matter the industry, one thing investors want from their company is earnings growth. While the utility industry is looked to for safety and yield, it’s still nice to see a company posting higher earnings.

This is one of the biggest problems with the Duke and Progress merger, since the union analysts have barely changed their earnings growth expectations. Prior to the merger, most analysts expected Duke to grow earnings by 2% to 3%; today, that number stands at 4.03%. This improvement might be okay, but it still represents the slowest growth of their peers.

Duke counts companies like Southern Co (NYSE: SO), Consolidated Edison (NYSE: ED), and Integrys (NYSE: TEG) as some of its peers. Each of these companies offers a solid dividend, but the difference is, two of the three are expected to grow earnings at a faster rate than Duke. In fact, Integrys is expected to see earnings growth of 5.5% and Southern is expected to grow by 4.8%. Only Consolidated Edison has a lower projected growth rate at 2.27%.

The growth that wasn’t
Sticking with the growth theme, Duke’s EPS was actually down 9.73% in the current quarter if you adjust for things like weather, and other changes. While the company gained about $0.44 per share in EPS, $0.35 of this was from the addition of Progress Energy, and $0.10 was from favorable weather.

This means Duke’s earnings would have been even worse if you strip out the addition of Progress and “favorable weather.” I don’t know about Duke investors, but I don’t want my utility relying on favorable weather to generate positive earnings growth. In addition, Duke’s peers did not have the same problem growing revenue and earnings. Integrys reported an impressive 34.48% jump in revenue, Southern Co reported a 4.9% increase, and even Consolidated Edison reported an increase of 3.44%. When your peers are growing and you are not, investors should take note.

Simple math
One of the biggest issues facing Duke is the company’s growth isn’t keeping up with the massive amount of shares the company issued to make this merger a reality. On a year-over-year basis, Duke’s share count is up 58%. However, looking at their core operating cash flow (net income + depreciation), this measure grew by 25%. In other words, Duke’s share count increased by an amount more than double the increase in operating income.

The same theme keeps playing out; Duke underperforms relative to their peers when it comes to operating cash flow growth as well. Leading the way once again was Integrys, which showed a 54% jump in core operating cash flow. While Southern Co came in second with a 33.7% increase, it seems like Consolidated Edison lagged Duke with a 13.65% increase. However, keep in mind, Consolidated Edison’s share count is up a scant 0.10% versus the 58% increase at Duke. Given the choice, I’ll take 13% growth in cash flow from a 0.10% increase in shares, versus a 25% increase from a 58% increase in shares any day.

Too many risks
If Duke’s questionable growth were my main issue with the stock, maybe some investors could overlook the problem and assume better days are ahead. However, there are several other issues investors need to face up to.

First, Duke’s interest expense as a percentage of operating income is higher than any of their peers. In fact, Duke pays about $0.30 of each $1 of operating income just in interest. By comparison, Consolidated Edison pays $0.27, Southern Co. pays $0.24, and Integrys pays just $0.10. In addition, Duke was core free cash flow negative by over $300 million in the current quarter.

When you add it all up, investors just aren’t being rewarded enough to own Duke at these levels. While it’s difficult to recommend Consolidated Edison at these levels, due to their lower yield and lower growth rate, Southern Co and Integrys look like much better values.

Both Southern Co and Integrys offer better yields than Duke. These companies also have better expected growth rates, and superior cash flow growth. If you are looking for dividend coverage, Integrys is the only one of the four to have a reasonable payout ratio of about 50% based on core free cash flow. For Duke investors, the merger with Progress looks like a failure so far. If investors want their portfolio to progress in the right direction, I would suggest switching to Southern Co or Integrys instead.


Chad Henage owns shares of Integrys Energy Group. The Motley Fool recommends Southern Company. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Is this post wrong? Click here. Think you can do better? Join us and write your own!

blog comments powered by Disqus

Compare Brokers

Fool Disclosure