Why Yahoo!'s Revenue Isn't Growing
Adrian is a member of The Motley Fool Blog Network -- entries represent the personal opinion of the blogger and are not formally edited.
I believe the best way to look at Yahoo! (NASDAQ: YHOO) is as a portfolio of IT businesses, and the latest earnings call confirmed my view once more.
One of the reasons for this sad fact is that Yahoo! continues experiencing serious advertisement problems. 17 acquisitions in a single year have not been able to fix this. Search and other revenue showed slight growth, but this was offset by a strong decline in revenue coming from ads display, as this segment fell 11% in the quarter versus the prior year to $423 million. Non-GAAP operating income, which is the kind of income you should see as it is a key determinant of free cash flow, actually decreased by 13% year over year to $209 million.
The core business isn't growing, but earnings are
However, not everything is bad news. In a similar fashion to traditional corporations who enjoy steady cash flow, but haven't experienced organic revenue growth for quite a while, Yahoo! used share repurchases and took advantage of some of its most promising investments to increase earnings artificially.
First of all, because of its promising equity investments in Alibaba and Yahoo! Japan, Yahoo! managed to increase non-GAAP net income by 6% from the second quarter to $386 million. The company received about $846 million from the redemption of the Alibaba Group preference shares and approximately $80 million in dividends from Yahoo! Japan!
Furthermore, they repurchased 45.3 million shares of stock in the quarter at an average price of $25.76, or $653 million, and spent $1 billion in acquisitions that was net of cash. All these factors have caused an amazing result: Yahoo!'s core business isn't growing at all, but earnings are growing artificially! And they were growing quite a lot: net income in this quarter rose about 46% from the same period of 2012, to $331 million, or $0.30 per share. Revenue fell 7% but net income rose 46%!
Is this actually good?
Well, nobody wants these kind of things to happen, specially after the company buys 17 startups to bring some growth to the table. However, the fact that Yahoo!'s core businesses are not growing doesn't mean this is a bad investment. Yahoo! is a special stock. Because most of its earnings come from the appreciation in value of some equity investments the company made in the past, when you buy Yahoo!, you are actually buying a sort of technology ETF: it gives you exposure to Yahoo! Japan and Alibaba, two promising IT businesses in Asia that have plenty of room for organic growth available.
Of course, Yahoo! is not always right about the investment it makes. No portfolio manager is! But the few times they happen to be right become so important for the stock that it can change everything. Just like the 24% stake in Alibaba is causing Yahoo!'s stock price to rise!
Is this sustainable? Well, at some moment investors will become more exigent about Yahoo!'s revenues figures. But it seems that won't happen any time soon, at least not this quarter. Being over optimistic at Yahoo! is, however, a clear mistake. There is no "turnaround" story here. At least not until now. And if 17 acquisitions in a single year didn't manage to bring some meaningful level of revenue to the table, then something really crucial is missing. Yahoo's CEO, Ms. Mayer, has made every effort to revitalize the core business in digital display advertising, yet the number of display ads sold has declined every quarter for the past two years. This quarter is no exception.
How to play this stock
Now that we have revisited what Yahoo! is and what Yahoo! isn't, let us discuss briefly some investment strategies. We know that Yahoo!'s core business isn't growing but we also know this could be a good stock, at least for a medium-term investment horizon, as there are abundant earnings coming from share repurchases and appreciation of equity. Even better, being long Yahoo! is somewhat equivalent to being long Alibaba before its IPO, which is said to be huge.
Adding Yahoo! to our portfolio could be interesting specially if we balance the Yahoo! effect with some stocks that have opposite features, who are growing their revenue quite fast, but are not profitable, at least not yet.
One example is Renren (NYSE: RENN). This Chinese social network stock is not profitable--in the latest earnings call it posted losses of $0.01 per share. However, it is about to break even and, even better, some of its businesses are experiencing massive revenue growth. Online gaming jumped 51%, as well as other non-advertising ventures. Its Groupon-like site, Nuomi.com, is an early star - sales increased over 100% year-over-year and user metrics continue to be solid.
Another interesting strategy consists of being long Yahoo! and at the same time being long its main competitor, Google (NASDAQ: GOOG). Unlike Yahoo!, Google's revenue in advertisement is growing and is quite healthy. With more than 80% of its net revenue generated by internet search, Google is the king and Yahoo!'s direct competitor in the search engine arena. The more Google grows its search engine and advertisement components, the less Yahoo! does.
So, by also adding Google to your portfolio, you could be hedging against a possible "come back to reality" Yahoo! correction in the next two quarters. And if such a correction does not materialize, even better! You will enjoy the benefits of a Yahoo! real turnaround, and also the benefits of owning Google, the biggest search engine in the world by far.
The bottom line
Yahoo! isn't your normal IT stock with fast growth an no profits. We can understand Yahoo! better by seeing it as a portfolio of IT businesses with attractive assets in Asia (the stakes in Alibaba and Yahoo! Japan). It's an IT ETF! That's not a bad thing, but if you are looking for growth stocks or value investments, you better consider other alternatives. If you are looking for interesting earnings and exposure to Asian markets, Yahoo! might do good to your portfolio. Keep in mind, though, that Yahoo! is struggling to change its ETF nature and bring some revenue growth to the table by doing aggressive acquisitions. So far, it has acquired 17 companies this year! The downside is that these efforts have not been able to boost revenue, and believing in a turnaround story is becoming increasingly harder.
It's incredible to think just how much of our digital and technological lives are almost entirely shaped and molded by just a handful of companies. Find out "Who Will Win the War Between the 5 Biggest Tech Stocks?" in The Motley Fool's latest free report, which details the knock-down, drag-out battle being waged by the five kings of tech. Click here to keep reading.
Adrian Campos has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Is this post wrong? Click here. Think you can do better? Join us and write your own!