Hewlett-Packard’s Rise Does Not Compute
Diane is a member of The Motley Fool Blog Network -- entries represent the personal opinion of the blogger and are not formally edited.
Hewlett-Packard (NYSE: HPQ) shares enjoyed a robust rally after the No. 1 personal computer maker reported better-than-expected quarterly results. Fueling the gains were a handful of upgrades and increased price targets from several Wall Street brokerage firms.
However, in a cautionary note, analysts warned the Palo Alto based company’s problems are far from over. Investors turned a deaf ear to the warning and sent shares up a good 16%. But the rally could be very short lived.
While it appears the cost cutting efforts set in motion by CEO Meg Whitman are working in her attempts to turn the struggling company around, there is plenty of work left to do. Whitman too was somewhat guarded as was underscored when she said in a conference call, “Although a number of business remains under pressure, the company’s blocking and tackling is improving.”
To date, HP shares have substantially improved and have outperformed all other Dow Jones Industrial Average components. Last year it was among the worst. Contributing to HP’s healthy gains in 2013 are the ongoing attempts to take rival Dell (NASDAQ: DELL) private and the vigorous M&A activity.
But Dell’s privatization has hit some snags as several big shareholder are vying for more than the $13.65 per share that CEO Michael Dell and Silver Lake Partners have outlined in the $24.4 billion LBO deal.
Shareholders just might get more. Dell just reported its fifth consecutive quarter of shrinking profits and the fourth of slumping revenue, but, despite the weakness in the PC business, the company remains highly profitable, and it is generating substantial free cash flow. In fact, Dell's net cash position swelled by $1 billion in the quarter to $6.2 billion, or some $3.50 a share.
Activist investor David Einhorn of Greenlight Capital recently noted in his quest to get Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) to share its hefty stash of cash that he sold his Dell position in 2012 because Mr. Dell wouldn't share the wealth.
By taking the company private, founder Mr. Dell can focus on longer-term investments, use its cash as it sees fit and engage in select strategies without the constant scrutiny of shareholders and analysts' prying eyes.
Like HP, Dell has been hurt by waning PC sales as consumers turn to a bevy of mobile devices. Also like HP, Dell has been trying to transform itself. Dell is attempting to morph into a more enterprise focused company emphasizing servers, software and services. That too has hit some snags as the company hasn’t been able to make the enterprise focused business grow at a fast enough clip to offset its slumping PC segment.
No question mobile is where it’s at. But even Apple has taken a beating as concerns mount over slowing iPhone sales and the company's ability to maintain its explosive growth. Since peaking at $705 in September 2012, Apple shares are down 36% from that lofty level, weighed down by scores of downgrades and institutional selling. Fiscal 2013 earnings have been revised downward by more than four dozen analysts. And as the Wall Street Journal reported, those downward revisions will probably be revised downward again. Because according to Michael Clement, an accounting professor at the University of Texas-Austin, who has studied analyst behavior extensively, a downward revision is more likely to be followed by yet another downward revision than an upward one.
Furthermore, Apple’s Mac sales slid 22% this holiday season from the same period a year ago. It marked the first time in more than six years that Apple’s Mac sales have not grown faster than the overall PC market, which shriveled 6% during the same quarter.
The kind of news does not bode well for HP. Whitman has much more than slipping PC sales to deal with. She came in amid a failed spin-off attempt, a bungled acquisition and in the wake of two CEOs who were shown the door.
Whitman squashed the decision to spin off HP’s PC division and plans to reduce headcount by 29,000. Following the earnings release, Whitman warned of a tough 2013. So don’t look for HP shares to “boot” up too much more.
It’s not only diminishing PC sales at HP that should be a cause of alarm for investors. Weak printer shipments, the overall decline of the market and future contract losses in services are also grave and mounting concerns. The sale of printers, copiers and related services add approximately 17% to HP's revenue. But the segment is under pressure as it continues to carry the lion's share of reined-in corporate spending.
So while HP’s latest news was better than expected, it was nothing to get excited about. Fundamentals remain weak at best. There are no "undo" buttons for that.
DianeAlter has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Apple. The Motley Fool owns shares of Apple. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Is this post wrong? Click here. Think you can do better? Join us and write your own!